Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sarah's avatar

I'd like to review what's happened from the POV of a reader:

- People in the SVU Twitter fandom made mean and hurtful comments about Kathy Stabler, some even celebrating her death. You were tagged in some of those posts, including one that's a popular Mean Girls meme.

- You felt hurt by these comments. You saw Kathy being disrespected and defiled, and you, the actor embodying that character for 12 years understandably found that hurtful.

- You made a choice to work through that hurt in a public forum and tag the White House Press Secretary regarding your blog post.

- You disappear after posting, and the narrative is completely lost and spun out of control. The creator of the meme (which you misrepresented as it included text about it being directed to Kathy Stabler that you chose to omit) is now getting death threats. Tweet after tweet seems to imply you, Isabel Gillies the person, received hate and vitriol. You don't step in to clarify.

- Your SVU colleagues retweet in what seems like a coordinated effort, amplifying your blog post exponentially. On Twitter there's a tangible sense of "pick up your pitchforks" against real, actual people. Not fictional people.

- You remain silent.

- Culminating with the White House Press Secretary weighing in, saying that a large part of the fandom has "poisonous venom pulsing through their veins." The. White. House. Press. Secretary.

- And yet, exactly one person in this situation has received a real, evidential death threat, and it's against the person who made the meme. You wrote about mob mentality against a fictional person and incited mob mentality against real people.

I'm glad you want to talk about being kind but boy did you blow it.

Expand full comment
Peanut's avatar

I'm totally confused. I opened this post expecting to read about hate mail and threats that Isabel received, and instead it's about the fictional character she portrays being bullied?? Talk about a bait and switch. I am sorry you were tagged in those posts, that was wrong. But like...you're a well-off white woman who got a paycheck for this acting gig, how badly do you expect us to feel for you for having for feelings hurt by a mean girls meme?

Expand full comment
192 more comments...

No posts